Who is running for U.S. House, Florida District 5 in 2026?
Here are the candidates for U.S. House, Florida District 5 on the November 3, 2026 ballot. This race is on the ballot for voters in U.S. House District 5.
Positions come only from each candidate's own votes, official actions, statements and questionnaire answers, never from party labels. Every item links to its source.
Side by side
Each candidate's position on the issues this office handles, from their own record. Details and sources are in each profile below.
| Issue | Rachel GrageDemocrat | William Lintag UphamIndependent | John H. RutherfordRepublican |
|---|---|---|---|
| Income taxes | No public position | No public position | Cut taxes across the board, including for top earners and corporationsVoted · medium |
| Safety net programs | No public position | No public position | Keep them, but add work requirements for able-bodied adultsVoted · medium |
| Healthcare | Keep the Affordable Care Act and fix what is brokenSaid · low | No public position | Private insurance with more competition and price transparency, keeping protections for pre-existing conditionsSaid · high |
| Abortion | No public position | No public position | Illegal, except to save the mother's life or in cases of rape or incestOfficial action · low |
| Guns | No public position | No public position | Remove most restrictions; bearing arms is a rightOfficial action · low |
| Immigration | No public position | No public position | Secure the border first; deport those with criminal records; keep legal immigration steadyVoted · medium |
| Politicians trading stocks | No public position | No public position | No, ban it for members and their spousesVoted · medium |
| Campaign finance | Keep spending legal but require groups to disclose their large donorsSaid · low | No public position | No single answer fits; see evidence |
| Mandatory minimums | No public position | No public position | Add or lengthen them for serious crimes like fentanyl traffickingVoted · medium |
| Student loans | No public position | No public position | Cap borrowing, simplify repayment, and skip broad forgivenessVoted · medium |
| Birthright citizenship | No public position | No public position | No, end it for children of parents here illegally or temporarilyOfficial action · medium |
| E-Verify mandate | No public position | No public position | Require it for all employersVoted · medium |
| Transgender athletes | No public position | No public position | No, and Congress should set a biological sex rule nationwideVoted · medium |
| Aid to Israel | No public position | No public position | Keep full aid without new conditionsVoted · medium |
| China policy | No public position | No public position | Get tougher: broad tariffs, state bans on land purchases, and forced app salesOfficial action · medium |
Rachel Grage
DemocratEngineer and health care professional
Rachel Grage earned bachelor's and master's degrees in engineering from Tulane University and worked as a biomedical engineer, and she has served as an elected president of her homeowner's association1. She is the Democratic candidate for Florida's 5th District and faces Republican incumbent John Rutherford and write-in candidate William Upham on November 3, 20262.
Where they stand 2 issues · tap any issue for the evidence
HealthcareKeep the Affordable Care Act and fix what is brokenlow
Said · low confidence- Her campaign site says she will work to keep health care premiums and prescription costs affordable and to maintain federal cost-sharing supports. (2026) source
Campaign financeKeep spending legal but require groups to disclose their large donorslow
Said · low confidence- Her campaign site says she will increase transparency in campaign finance and reduce the influence of big money in politics. (2026) source
No public position found on: Income taxes, National debt, Social Security, Safety net programs, Minimum wage, Business regulation, Abortion, Guns, Immigration, Trade and tariffs, Foreign policy, Energy and climate, Judges, Politicians trading stocks, Marijuana, Redistricting, Term limits, Electoral College, Supreme Court reform, Death penalty, Qualified immunity, Mandatory minimums, Drug prices, Childcare and pre-K, Paid leave, Student loans, AI regulation, Kids online, School vaccines, Nuclear power, Birthright citizenship, E-Verify mandate, Transgender athletes, DEI programs, Religion in schools, Aid to Israel, Aid to Ukraine, China policy.
William Lintag Upham
IndependentPrivate citizen
William Upham describes himself on his campaign site as a Marine, a prosecutor and a Republican who is running as a write-in candidate for Florida's 5th District1. He is listed by the Division of Elections as a qualified write-in candidate and faces Republican incumbent John Rutherford and Democrat Rachel Grage on November 3, 20262.
No public position found on: Income taxes, National debt, Social Security, Safety net programs, Minimum wage, Business regulation, Healthcare, Abortion, Guns, Immigration, Trade and tariffs, Foreign policy, Energy and climate, Judges, Politicians trading stocks, Marijuana, Redistricting, Term limits, Campaign finance, Electoral College, Supreme Court reform, Death penalty, Qualified immunity, Mandatory minimums, Drug prices, Childcare and pre-K, Paid leave, Student loans, AI regulation, Kids online, School vaccines, Nuclear power, Birthright citizenship, E-Verify mandate, Transgender athletes, DEI programs, Religion in schools, Aid to Israel, Aid to Ukraine, China policy.
John H. Rutherford
Republican · IncumbentU.S. Representative, Florida District 5
John Rutherford is a former police officer who was elected three times as sheriff of Duval County and has served in the U.S. House since January 2017, representing District 4 until 2023 and District 5 since12. He serves on the Appropriations Committee38. He faces Democrat Rachel Grage and write-in candidate William Upham on November 3, 20263.
Where they stand 23 issues · tap any issue for the evidence
HealthcarePrivate insurance with more competition and price transparency, keeping protections for pre-existing conditionshigh
Said · high confidence- Voted for the Lower Health Care Premiums for All Americans Act, which expanded association health plans and required drug middleman (PBM) price transparency. (2025-12-17) source
- His House site says the Affordable Care Act brought higher premiums, larger deductibles and fewer choices, and calls for affordable care that covers people with pre-existing conditions and gives families greater choice in coverage. (2026) source
Income taxesCut taxes across the board, including for top earners and corporationsmedium
Voted · medium confidence- Voted against the Inflation Reduction Act, which set a 15% minimum tax on large corporations to help pay for energy and health programs. (2022-08-12) source
- Voted for the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, which made the 2017 individual tax cuts permanent, including the 37% top rate, and extended business tax breaks. (2025-07-03) source
Safety net programsKeep them, but add work requirements for able-bodied adultsmedium
Voted · medium confidenceImmigrationSecure the border first; deport those with criminal records; keep legal immigration steadymedium
Voted · medium confidence- Voted against the American Dream and Promise Act, which offered a path to citizenship for Dreamers. (2021-03-18) source
- Voted against the Farm Workforce Modernization Act, which offered legal status to long-time farmworkers. (2021-03-18) source
- Voted for the Secure the Border Act, which funded border wall construction, tightened asylum rules and required E-Verify. (2023-05-11) source
- Voted for the Secure America Act, which provides about $70 billion for immigration enforcement and border security through 2029. (2026-06-09) source
- His House site says the U.S. government must uphold its own immigration laws and prioritize the protection of citizens, and lists cosponsoring the El Chapo Act to fund the border wall. (2026) source
Politicians trading stocksNo, ban it for members and their spousesmedium
Voted · medium confidence- Voted for the Stop Insider Trading Act, which bars members of Congress, their spouses and dependents from buying new individual stocks. (2026-07-22) source
Mandatory minimumsAdd or lengthen them for serious crimes like fentanyl traffickingmedium
Voted · medium confidence- Voted for the HALT Fentanyl Act, which permanently classifies fentanyl-related substances as Schedule I and applies mandatory minimum sentences to trafficking them. (2023-05-25) source
- Voted for the HALT Fentanyl Act, which permanently classifies fentanyl-related substances as Schedule I and applies mandatory minimum sentences to trafficking them. (2025-06-12) source
Student loansCap borrowing, simplify repayment, and skip broad forgivenessmedium
E-Verify mandateRequire it for all employersmedium
Voted · medium confidence- Voted for the Secure the Border Act, which would require all employers to use E-Verify. (2023-05-11) source
Birthright citizenshipNo, end it for children of parents here illegally or temporarilymedium
Official action · medium confidence- Cosponsored the Birthright Citizenship Act of 2025, which would limit automatic citizenship to children with at least one parent who is a citizen, a lawful permanent resident, or a noncitizen serving in the military. (2025) source
Transgender athletesNo, and Congress should set a biological sex rule nationwidemedium
Voted · medium confidence- Voted for the Protection of Women and Girls in Sports Act, a federal rule basing girls' and women's school sports eligibility on sex at birth. (2023-04-20) source
- Voted for the Protection of Women and Girls in Sports Act, a federal rule basing girls' and women's school sports eligibility on sex at birth. (2025-01-14) source
Aid to IsraelKeep full aid without new conditionsmedium
China policyGet tougher: broad tariffs, state bans on land purchases, and forced app salesmedium
Official action · medium confidence- Cosponsored the Prohibition of Agricultural Land for the People's Republic of China Act in 2023, which would prohibit certain persons from purchasing agricultural real estate in the United States. (2023) source
AbortionIllegal, except to save the mother's life or in cases of rape or incestlow
Official action · low confidence- Voted against the Women's Health Protection Act, which would protect abortion access nationwide before viability. (2021-09-24) source
- Voted against the Women's Health Protection Act of 2022, which would protect abortion access nationwide before viability. (2022-07-15) source
- Original cosponsor of the Life at Conception Act (H.R. 722) in 2025, which would protect life from fertilization and lists no exceptions. (2025) source
GunsRemove most restrictions; bearing arms is a rightlow
Energy and climateNo single answer fitslow
Voted · low confidenceMarijuanaNo single answer fitslow
Voted · low confidence- Voted against the MORE Act, which would legalize marijuana federally and clear past convictions. (2022-04-01) source
RedistrictingNo single answer fitslow
Voted · low confidence- Voted against the For the People Act, which would require independent redistricting commissions. (2021-03-03) source
Campaign financeNo single answer fitslow
Voted · low confidence- Voted against the For the People Act, which created public matching funds for campaigns and stricter donor disclosure. (2021-03-03) source
Qualified immunityNo single answer fitslow
Voted · low confidence- Voted against the George Floyd Justice in Policing Act, which would end qualified immunity for police officers. (2021-03-03) source
Drug pricesNo single answer fitslow
Voted · low confidence- Voted against the Affordable Insulin Now Act, which would cap insulin costs at $35 a month. (2022-03-31) source
Childcare and pre-KNo single answer fitslow
Voted · low confidence- Voted against the Build Back Better Act, which funded free universal pre-K and expanded childcare aid. (2021-11-19) source
Paid leaveNo single answer fitslow
Voted · low confidence- Voted against the Build Back Better Act, which created a national paid family and medical leave program. (2021-11-19) source
Aid to UkraineNo single answer fitslow
Voted · low confidence
No public position found on: National debt, Social Security, Minimum wage, Business regulation, Trade and tariffs, Foreign policy, Judges, Term limits, Electoral College, Supreme Court reform, Death penalty, AI regulation, Kids online, School vaccines, Nuclear power, DEI programs, Religion in schools.
Last reviewed 2026-10-06. Spotted something wrong? Every claim links to its source so you can check it yourself.